Drug testing for welfare recipients has become a hot button issue across America. In fact, legislation requiring drug testing for welfare recipients was proposed in 29 states over the last year, and passed in 8 states. With the argument raging on both sides of party lines and welfare drug testing statistics being thrown around, Americans are weighing in with their opinions.
Here is a
look at the most common arguments being used on each side in the welfare drug
testing argument:
Pro-Drug Testing Arguments
Drug Testing Welfare Recipients is Fiscally Responsible
Proponents
believe that it is fiscally irresponsible to use taxpayer dollars to subsidize
the use of illegal drugs. Therefore, drug testing would ensure that taxpayer
dollars would be used wisely to help individuals that need assistance and are
going to use the money the way it was intended – for necessities, rather than
illegal leisure activities.
Testing Incentivizes Drug Users to Get Clean
By
withholding badly needed welfare dollars as a result of a positive drug test,
it incentivizes recipients to stay clean. Getting individuals off of drugs
tackles the root of the problem, instead of ignoring the addictions that are
keeping them down.
Drug Testing is Required by Employers Too
Drug testing
welfare recipients is not a new concept – many private employers drug test
employees upon hire as a condition of employment, and some even drug test
employees regularly. If drug testing is required for many members of the work
force, why is it a big deal to require it for the unemployed as well?
Welfare Given to Drug Addicts isn’t Helping their Families
When welfare
is given to drug addicts the money is not being spent to take care of their
families. Instead, addicts are likely to squander the money without it ever
making it to children and other dependents.
If Taxpayers are Funding Welfare, they should be Allowed to Regulate It
The argument
here is that the people who are funding welfare should have a say as to what is
happening with their money. Voters who cast ballots in favor of drug testing
for welfare recipients, or other welfare reform measures, are voicing their
desire to ensure that the money is going to people who need it most and will
use it responsible ways.
Anti-Drug Testing Arguments
Mandatory Drug Testing is a Violation of Human Rights
Forcing
people who are down on their luck to take a drug test is not only embarrassing
and humiliating, but also a violation of rights. Subjecting the needy to drug
testing stigmatizes financial need in a way that can be degrading to a
population of people who may have just caught a bad break.
Denying Welfare to Drug Users Unfairly Punishes Families
Drug users
are someone’s parents, siblings, and children. Withholding welfare from these
people means that their dependents will go without. It’s not fair to punish
these people (especially minors) for someone else’s discretions.
Welfare Money is Not being used to Buy Drugs
While
everyone can agree that taxpayer dollars shouldn’t be handed out to pay for
illegal recreational drugs, giving welfare to drug users does not mean that
that is how they are using the money. Even drug addicts still have basic human
needs, and welfare ensures that these needs will be met.
There are Better Solutions
Everyone can
agree that the current welfare system is flawed and needs ongoing oversight and
reform to function optimally, but drug testing can get expensive. A better,
more cost-effective, solution is to further restrict how EBT cards can be used.
Where do you draw the Line?
The argument
against drug testing welfare recipients is not simply limited to welfare.
Opponents ask “If you’re going to drug test for welfare, where do you draw the
line?” Is drug testing going to be required for student aid and grants? What
about public research grants? The concern is that regulation of this sort will
spiral out of control and just go too far.
Regardless
of what you believe about this important and controversial topic, there are
many factors at play to consider. Did we miss anything in our analysis of the
issues? Tell us below!
Amazing place, amazing staff especially Fitness experts, staff will make you seem like you’re friends. Usually, I am going late and you will find not allot of people in order to easily make use of all the machines even in busy times individuals are very cooperative. They have an additional room for aerobics and dance classes which I use allot for my cardio, a great deal of equipment at www.john14-6.org.
ReplyDeleteI discovered the right place; also it was in my price range. It does not enhance price compares. All that you should do is actually gone into the criteria for your type of hotel and solutions you would like. Inexpensive resort booking site strolls you through the procedure, so it's simple at ratecompares.com.
ReplyDeleteI can’t believe this is really true I never believe there is cure to this hsv 2 because all the hospital have told me there is no cure to it, few months ago I saw this man email DR.AZIEGBE on internet from a testimony share by someone who he help with his herbal cure I contact his email and ask for his help also, that is how he inform me about the cure process and this man sent me a herbal medicine which I took according to the way he instructed for 2 week I can’t believe when I go for test my result come out negative i am so happy to share this to the world there is real cure to herpes you can also contact DR.AZIEGBE through his email now DRAZIEGBE1SPELLHOME@GMAIL.COM and also WhatsApp him +2349035465208. or my assistant text me +1 (601) 452-8622 or email: JAMESAVA0001@GMAIL.COM...
ReplyDeleteWhile small, it's nonetheless a very succesful machine and one of the inexpensive options on our record, which just goes to Men’s Loafer Slippers show out|to indicate} that you just want to|need not|needn't} drop a massive stack of cash to get began with the interest. This is incredible for printing miniatures and other detailed fashions at a minute scale, and the small size of the machine means might be} proper at residence on just about any shelf or desk, offering there's respectable ventilation. It lacks a built-in filter and it's fairly expensive, but you're paying for high quality so we wouldn't consider it overpriced contemplating the detail it could possibly} obtain. Its sheer size could be be} an issue for some as it isn't going to suit onto a standard desk, but if you have a table or massive workbench, then the huge dimensions are completely worth it and it turns into one of the best 3D printers. While dental 3D printers are sometimes used to printing only one or two components at a time, many instances require the rapid fabrication of {a massive number of|numerous|a lot of} components.
ReplyDelete